Reindeer Cookies

Are you a Nutter Butter fan?  I am, and one of my viewers commented on my YouTube Channel and pointed out that the Nutter Butter Cookies are underrated and I agree with her!  I don’t know when I grew fond of Nutter Butter Cookies, but I found it to be delicious and satisfying.  To make the Nutter Butters even better, try dipping the cookies in dark chocolate, so good!


Putting these Reindeer cookies were simple, however when placing the eyes on the cookie, just be careful not to let the eye flip because once it flips over and the white becomes dark, the cookies end up looking like a scary cookie.

Reindeer Cookies

Reindeer Cookies
  • green sprinkles
  • red M&Ms
  • eyes
  • 2 tablespoons shortening
  • nutter butters
  • pretzels
  • 12 oz dark chocolate candy melts
  • popsicle stick
  1. Follow the instructions to melt the dark chocolate and once it's melted add the shortening and mix.
  2. Grab the cookie open it up, grab the popsicle stick dip in chocolate, place between the cookies and close the cookie. Wait about 10 seconds and dip the cookie in the chocolate.
  3. Grab the pretzel(s) and dip in the chocolate and place on the cookie, place eyes, M&M and green sprinkle and let it sit for a couple of minutes before handling it.


For a step-by-step tutorial of this recipe you can watch my video tutorial below. SUBSCRIBE TO MY YOUTUBE CHANNEL and never miss a recipe! (It’s free!) and new video posts on FRIDAYS !


Related posts:

Leave a Comment: